Looking for the finest dining experiences in Plettenberg Bay? As local experts, we’ve curated this insider’s guide to the best restaurants in Plett, from upscale dining to casual favorites. Whether you’re craving fresh seafood, seeking romantic sunset views, or hunting for the perfect breakfast spot, this guide has you covered.
1. Emily Moon River Lodge
Price Range: $$$ | Cuisine: Contemporary South African Location: Rietvlei Road, Plettenberg Bay
Perched above the Bitou River, Emily Moon isn’t just a restaurant—it’s a dining destination. This bohemian-chic establishment offers one of the most romantic settings in Plett.
What to Order:
- Starter: Gin-cured salmon with citrus segments
- Main: Grass-fed beef fillet with bone marrow butter
- Dessert: Dark chocolate tart with salted caramel
Pro Tip: Book a table for sunset and arrive 30 minutes early to enjoy drinks on the deck. Reservations essential, especially during peak season.
2. The Fat Fish
Price Range: $$-$$$ | Cuisine: Seafood Location: Beacon House, Beacon Isle Crescent
With panoramic ocean views and the freshest seafood in town, The Fat Fish has earned its reputation as Plett’s premier seafood destination.
Must-Try Dishes:
- Fresh oysters (when in season)
- Linefish with lemon butter sauce
- Seafood pasta
Insider Tip: Request a window table when booking. Their early bird special (5-7 PM) offers excellent value.
3. Enrico’s Restaurant
Price Range: $$ | Cuisine: Italian/Seafood Location: Keurboomstrand
Famous for its dramatic oceanfront location, Enrico’s serves authentic Italian cuisine with a South African twist.
Signature Dishes:
- Fresh mussels in white wine sauce
- Wood-fired pizzas
- Homemade pasta
Local Secret: The restaurant is particularly magical during whale-watching season (June-November).
4. The Grand Africa Café & Beach
Price Range: $$$ | Cuisine: Mediterranean Location: Lookout Beach
A newer addition to Plett’s dining scene, The Grand Africa brings sophisticated beach dining to the Garden Route.
Highlights:
- Extensive wine list
- Fresh seafood platters
- Beach-front dining
Best For: Sundowners and sophisticated dinner parties.
5. Nineteen89
Price Range: $$ | Cuisine: Contemporary Location: Main Street
A local favorite for its consistent quality and innovative menu, Nineteen89 offers a perfect blend of casual and upscale dining.
Popular Choices:
- Pulled pork tacos
- Gourmet burgers
- Craft cocktails
6. Le Fournil de Plett
Price Range: $ | Cuisine: French Bakery/Café Location: Market Square
The best breakfast spot in town, featuring authentic French pastries and excellent coffee.
Don’t Miss:
- Fresh croissants
- Eggs Benedict
- Artisanal breads
7. The Med Seafood Bistro
Price Range: $$ | Cuisine: Mediterranean/Seafood Location: Market Square
A consistent performer offering reliable quality and generous portions.
Recommended:
- Seafood curry
- Greek mezze platters
- Fresh line fish
8. Mobys Seafood & Grill
Price Range: $$ | Cuisine: Seafood/Steakhouse Location: Beacon Isle Crescent
A long-standing favorite combining quality seafood with excellent steaks.
Best Known For:
- Combo platters
- Prawns
- Aged steaks
9. The Bungalow
Price Range: $$ | Cuisine: Contemporary/Beach Bar Location: Hobie Beach
Perfect for casual dining with stunning ocean views.
Specialties:
- Gourmet burgers
- Fresh salads
- Craft cocktails
10. Off The Hook
Price Range: $$ | Cuisine: Seafood/Sushi Location: Main Street
Outstanding sushi and seafood in a relaxed setting.
Must-Try:
- Fresh sushi platters
- Poke bowls
- Tempura prawns
Essential Dining Tips for Plettenberg Bay
Reservations
- Book at least 2-3 days in advance for upscale restaurants
- Essential during peak season (December-January)
- Most restaurants accept WhatsApp bookings
Best Times to Dine
- Lunch: 12:00-14:00
- Dinner: 18:00-20:00
- Early bird specials typically 17:00-18:30
Seasonal Considerations
- Peak season (December-January): Book weeks in advance
- Whale season (June-November): Request window tables
- Off-peak: Many restaurants offer special deals
Getting Around
Most restaurants in central Plettenberg Bay are within walking distance of major hotels and accommodations. For venues like Emily Moon and Enrico’s, we recommend arranging transport.
Looking for the perfect place to stay while exploring Plettenberg Bay’s culinary scene? Check out our luxury oceanfront apartment, centrally located and walking distance to many of these fantastic restaurants.
